Perfectionism shows up in my sessions more than almost any other personality trait. The problem is that perfectionism, applied to eating, almost always backfires.
What Perfectionism Looks Like Around Food
It looks like planning a perfectly balanced meal and then feeling like a failure when you eat something off-plan. It looks like "I already messed up today, I might as well start over Monday." It looks like eating perfectly for three weeks and then abandoning everything completely when life gets chaotic.
The all-or-nothing pattern is perfectionism's most common expression. If I can't do it perfectly, why do it at all? And the answer — in terms of nutrition — is almost always "do it imperfectly anyway," because imperfect consistency beats perfect plans executed briefly.
Why the Perfect Diet Doesn't Exist
There is no single dietary pattern that is universally optimal for every person, at every stage of life, in every context. When clients come in looking for the perfect diet, one of the most useful things I can do is tell them honestly: it doesn't exist. What exists is a range of reasonable approaches, and within that range, the one that works for you is the one you can sustain.
Done consistently is always better than done perfectly. Always.
What I Work On With Perfectionist Clients
The first thing is redefining success. Instead of "I ate perfectly today," the goal becomes "I made mostly nourishing choices today." We also practice the 80/20 frame: if 80% of your eating is nourishing and intentional, the other 20% — the birthday cake, the restaurant meal, the tired Tuesday — isn't a problem. It's just part of living.
If perfectionism is getting in the way of your health, let's talk about it.
Book a Session